Allison needs to pick a guy who's funny, treats the guy well, dorky, and not too serious for her best friend Alan. The guys have to write poetry for Alan and perform it. Abel (eliminated with Mark) Evan (WINNER) Mark (eliminated with Abel) Eric (eliminated) Alison chooses Evan because he's a lot of fun and seems like Alan's type. Alan and Evan's Date: Alan was nervous because he's very good looking and Evan thinks Alan is cute. They start to make some small talk. Alan thinks Evan is funny and loves that he likes to tell stories because he likes to be entertained and Evan likes that Alan is sarcastic. They get to know each other on a deeper level when they talk about ""coming out"": Alan's parents still love him and wanted to talk about everything and Evan's parents know that he is gay but they haven't really talked about it yet. They then go to this place where they have to play pool handcuffed. While in the car, they talk about gay marriage and how they wouldn't want to be called